Is Stretching Bad for Muscle Growth?

Custom Keto Diet

Is Stretching Bad for Muscle Growth?


How does stretching before you lift weights, or between sets, affect muscle growth? Does it speed it up, slow it down, or have no effect at all?

To answer that question, a team of Brazilian scientists set up a very simple experiment [1].

They rounded up a group of men, and got them to train their legs twice a week on the leg extension machine.

With leg extensions, you normally work both legs together. But in this study, the men trained one leg at a time. This meant that each leg could be exercised under slightly different conditions.

It’s an elegant way to design a study, mainly because it takes genetics, lifestyle and diet out of the equation [2].

When you use different groups of people to compare training protocols, the food they eat, the life they live, and the genes they were born with can skew the results. But with the “unilateral exercise model” as it’s known, nutrition, lifestyle and genetics are identical for both legs.

The men taking part in the study did four sets to failure, using a weight that was around 80% of their one-rep max.

The only difference was that one of the legs was stretched for a total of 50 seconds immediately prior to the first set. This allowed the researchers to see how stretching affected gains in size and strength.

Is Stretching Before Lifting Bad for Muscle Growth?

After 10 weeks, the muscles in both legs were bigger than they were at the start of the study. But the leg that had been stretched grew much more slowly. In fact, muscle growth in the unstretched leg was over 70% greater compared to the stretched leg.

Interestingly, not everyone responded to stretching in the same way.

In four subjects, stretching led to a drop in the rate of growth. Three subjects posted very similar gains in both the stretched and unstretched legs. In one individual, muscles in the stretched leg actually grew slightly faster.

So what’s going on? Why did stretching put the brakes on muscle growth?

The difference in gains between the stretched and unstretched legs appears to have been caused by stretching reducing the amount of work the men were able to do.

In the first five weeks of the study, they averaged 37 reps across all four sets in the unstretched leg. But in the stretched leg, that number was just 30 reps.

It was much the same story from weeks 6 to 10, where stretching cut the total number of reps from 46 to 39. In fact, total training volume (defined in this study as weight multiplied by reps) in the stretched leg was down by around 20%.

Static Stretching and Repetition Strength

This isn’t an isolated finding that contradicts a sea of existing data on the subject, and there are plenty of studies out there showing much the same thing.

And we’re not just talking about a rep or two. Static stretching has been shown to cut repetition strength – the number of reps you’re able to do with a given weight – by somewhere in the region of 20% [3, 4].

There are plenty of theories as to why stretching affects strength in this way, from changes in the nervous system (meaning that fewer muscle fibers are called into action during an exercise, and a certain portion of the muscle never gets trained) to alterations in the “stiffness” of muscles and tendons, leading to a reduction in the transmission of force between muscle and bone [5].

Whatever the reason, the takeaway is clear:

If you want to build muscle as fast as humanly possible, you should avoid stretching before you lift weights.

Or should you?

Not necessarily.

Why Stretching Isn’t Killing Your Gains

For one, not all forms of stretching have been shown to harm your performance, especially when the length of each stretch is relatively short.

In one study, a single stretch lasting 20 seconds had no adverse effect on repetition strength, while a 40-second stretch did [6].

In another, 90 seconds of static stretching (3 x 30 seconds, separated by 30 seconds of rest) had no significant effect on repetition strength in the bench press and leg extension [7].

Brazilian scientists found that even 80 seconds of static stretching prior to lifting weights failed to put the brakes on muscle growth [8].

Much of the research that shows stretching harms performance involves a large amount of pre-exercise stretching, far more than most people are doing in the gym [9].

In one study, stretching the biceps for six minutes immediately prior to a strength test reduced strength by around 5% [10]. In another, thirty minutes of stretching led to a 30% drop in strength immediately following the stretch [11]. After five minutes, strength was still down by around 20%. Even one hour later, full strength had still not returned.

But who’s stretching a single muscle group for 30 minutes, or even six minutes, before they lift weights? I’m not, and you’re probably not either.

Interset Stretching and Muscle Growth

More interesting still, there is research to show that stretching between sets – which is essentially multiple bouts of pre-exercise stretching – leads to a faster rate of growth than just sitting around doing nothing [12].

In fact, subjects who stretched the muscles they were working between each set (that is, they stretched their chest between sets of the bench press, their lats between sets of seated rows, their quads between sets of leg extensions, and so on), saw gains in muscle thickness that were were roughly 50% greater than their counterparts in the passive rest group.

The main stimulus for hypertrophy is mechanical tension, and this tension can be produced by actively contracting your muscles or passive resistance to stretch. In fact, research shows that stretching can trigger muscle protein synthesis, albeit to a smaller degree than muscular contractions [13].

Although a fifty percent increase in the rate of muscle growth sounds impressive, it’s worth pointing out that it was measured in untrained subjects, doing a relatively small number of hard sets each week.

Given that there’s an upper limit on the amount of stimulation your muscles can respond to in any given workout, stretching between sets isn’t necessarily going to deliver the same results if you’re doing a higher volume of training. Nor is someone with several years of serious lifting behind them likely to see the same kind of results.

Thirty seconds of interset stretching may well have been below the threshold required to reduce repetition strength. But we don’t know for sure, as the researchers didn’t measure training volume, so we don’t know if stretching between sets had an adverse effect on performance.

Finally, there aren’t many studies to look at how interset stretching affects gains in muscle size, and the years to come may see this paper buried in an avalanche of research showing the exact opposite.

Still, it’s an interesting finding, and offers some support for the claim that stretching between sets can help your gains, an idea that’s been doing the rounds in bodybuilding circles for many years.

Here’s what Arnold Schwarzenegger had to say on the subject in his Encyclopedia of Modern Bodybuilding:

“I believe it is also essential to do certain kinds of stretching during your training. Just as I recommend flexing and posing the muscles between sets, I also believe in stretching certain muscles between one set and the next. The lats, for example, benefit from careful stretching interspersed with various chinning and pulldown movements.?

Final Thoughts

Do a large amount of stretching for a single muscle group, and then attempt some kind of maximal effort in a task involving that exact same muscle group. The chances are high that you’ll perform worse compared to the same task done without stretching.

But I don’t know anyone who is doing that, and the stretching protocols used in many studies are very different from what most people are doing in the gym.

The extent to which stretching affects performance depends on the amount and type of stretching you’re doing, how much of a gap you leave between stretching and hitting the weights, and the type of training that follows the stretch (i.e. strength/power training vs bodybuilding-style workouts).

In short, stretching before you lift weights isn’t automatically going to kill your gains, and relatively short periods of stretching between sets may end up helping rather than hurting muscle growth.

SEE ALSO: THE MUSCLE BUILDING CHEAT SHEET

If you’re fed up spending hours in the gym with nothing to show for it, then check out The Muscle Building Cheat Sheet.

It’s a “cut the waffle and just tell me what to do” PDF that tells you exactly how to go about building muscle. To get a copy of the cheat sheet sent to you, please click or tap here to enter your email address.

Muscle Building Cheat Sheet

ABOUT THE AUTHOR

Christian FinnChristian Finn is the nation’s leading authority on science-based, joint-friendly ways to build muscle. A former “trainer to the trainers,” he holds a masters degree in exercise science, and has been featured in or contributed to major media on two continents, including the BBC and Sunday Times in the U.K. and Men’s Health and Men’s Fitness in the U.S.



Read More

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *